New Jersey Joins 44 Attorneys General Opposing CFTC Prediction-Market Rules

The coalition says the agency’s approach could displace state gambling safeguards for sports and election contracts.
Key points
  • New Jersey and Ohio led a bipartisan coalition of 44 attorneys general in comments against two CFTC rulemakings.
  • The states want the agency to withdraw its proposed sports-event-contract rule and reject the classification of sports bets as swaps.
  • They argue that federal treatment of peer-to-peer event contracts could weaken state licensing, age-limit and responsible-gambling safeguards.
  • The CFTC maintains that event contracts are commodity derivatives within its exclusive authority under the Commodity Exchange Act.
  • The dispute comes as New Jersey seeks Supreme Court review of its separate case against Kalshi.
New Jersey Joins 44 Attorneys General Opposing CFTC Prediction-Market Rules

New Jersey Attorney General Jennifer Davenport has joined Ohio Attorney General Andy Wilson in leading a bipartisan group of 44 attorneys general against two Commodity Futures Trading Commission rulemakings affecting sports betting and prediction markets.

The group includes 43 state attorneys general and the attorney general for the District of Columbia. In formal comments, it urged the CFTC to withdraw its proposed rule defining sports-event contracts as swaps and to state clearly that sports-betting contracts are not financial derivatives within the agency’s jurisdiction.

The coalition also objected to an interim rule already in force. New Jersey’s attorney general said the measure distinguishes house-backed casino-style games from arrangements in which participants wager against one another. The states contend that, taken together, the rulemakings could bring peer-to-peer sports and election betting under exclusive federal oversight.

Davenport said the CFTC was seeking to regulate forms of sports gambling beyond its proper remit. The coalition argues that the agency lacks authority to address gambling-related harms, exceeded the rulemaking power Congress granted it and did not follow required procedures.

The attorneys general say the approach would let prediction-market operators bypass state licensing requirements, age limits and problem-gambling protections. They also warned that conventional sportsbooks could reorganize as prediction markets to avoid state gambling laws. Kalshi and Polymarket offer contracts on such matters as game winners, point spreads and player statistics, while claiming CFTC-regulated status that exempts them from state gambling rules.

The CFTC published its proposed rule on Oct. 9. It would classify contracts tied to sports, politics, culture and weather as swaps. CFTC Chairman Michael S. Selig has said event contracts are commodity derivatives within the agency’s exclusive jurisdiction under the Commodity Exchange Act, and that they are used to hedge risk, speculate and provide information about future outcomes.

The rulemaking follows conflicting federal appellate decisions. The Third Circuit found sports-event contracts traded on a licensed designated contract market met the Commodity Exchange Act’s definition of a swap, while the Sixth and Ninth Circuits reached the opposite conclusion.

The intervention adds another front to New Jersey’s continuing challenge to prediction-market regulation. The state is seeking Supreme Court review of its case against Kalshi, a bid supported by 39 states, Washington, D.C., and 146 tribal nations and tribal organizations.

The CFTC has said registered prediction markets generated more than $25 billion in trading volume during 2025, underscoring the commercial stakes in the dispute over which level of government regulates the products.

21+ in OH. Please play responsibly. For help, call the Ohio Problem Gambling Helpline at 1-800-589-9966 or 1-800-GAMBLER.

Latest news